Review:The cover might fool you into thinking this was released during the Quesada/Jemas days, since the company name is written across the top and there’s no corner box (the new look adopted to signal Marvel’s new direction in 2001). Plus, the interiors bring us lower-case lettering, when the X-Babies speak at least, another “innovation” from the Quesada/Jemas era. The comic’s actually from the final year of the Bob Harras days, however. It might be tempting to think this comic influenced the future look of Marvel Comics, but I can’t imagine any of Bob Harras’ replacements ever glanced at it. I don’t even recall much of a fan response to this one-shot, even though the first one was received fairly well. X-specials were far from “special” at this point, and virtually anything with the X-Babies on the cover was probably automatically rendered unimportant to most readers. And fans of the original one-shot possibly didn’t even know this existed, because I certainly don’t remember any promotion for it.
X-Babies Reborn
isn’t as much fun as its predecessor, but it has its moments. Aside
from some cute jokes, including a running gag about where babies come
from and the introduction of ninja-baby Psylocke, there is some
legitimately good character work between Sugah and Psychilde that evokes
a Claremontian feel without turning the sentiment into parody. The
plot has more than its share of puzzling diversions, however, such as a
detour to an abandoned library that doesn’t seem to serve much of a
purpose outside of making a joke about kids not reading books anymore.
Too often the story just feels padded in order to fill up the
double-sized page count. Like the previous one-shot, the real highlight
of the issue is J. J. Kirby’s art. I think his X-Babies rival the
original Arthur Adams’ versions, and the ‘Vengers are great cartoony
reinventions the heroes (especially tiny Hawkeye and Iron Man.) If
Kirby could apply this style to six-foot superheroes, I don’t see how he
couldn’t have had Ed McGuinness’ career.



