The Rising Storm!
Credits:
Chris Claremont (writer), Tom Grummett and Peter Vale (pencils), Al
Vey, Gary Martin, and Terry Pallot (inks), Wilfredo Quintana (colors),
Tom Orzechowski (letters)
Summary:
Storm arrives in Wakanda, seeking sanctuary. Against Nick Fury’s
counsel, Black Panther grants it to her. She spends months earning
Wakanda’s trust, and eventually Black Panther proposes marriage. On
their wedding day, Killmonger enters the palace and murders Black
Panther. Storm arranged the attack with Killmonger, but tells
Killmonger that she won’t be second to anyone. She kills him, then
destroys the scene of the crime with lightning. When she emerges from
the rubble, the people of Wakanda name Storm their new queen.
Continuity Note: Everett K. Ross, a supporting cast member from the Christopher Priest Black Panther run, makes a cameo. Ross had not been created at the point X-Men Forever continuity is supposed to have diverged, but I suppose his presence doesn’t cause any real harm to the premise of the series.
Production Note: An eight-page Marvel Saga style text piece explains what various characters in the Marvel Universe were doing when X-Men Forever supposedly takes place.
Review:
Storm, or Perfect Storm or Evil Storm if you prefer, receives the
spotlight this issue. The story is set over the course of several
months, detailing Storm’s actions after escaping the X-Men and providing
a Cliff’s Notes
version of how she’s become ruler of Wakanda. Laying out all of this
information in one issue would seem to go against Claremont’s instincts,
since this is the type of story he would normally save for a slow-burning
subplot. Given the bi-weekly schedule of this book, I’m not sure why
exactly he hasn’t been developing this storyline gradually over the
course of the series so far. I would say the past few issues have had
enough space to dramatize the plot; it’s not as if the previous arc
needed so many splash pages of the X-Men fighting werewolves, if we’re
being honest.
Regardless,
Claremont’s getting to the point now and moving Storm into position as Evil Queen Ororo. Relocating her to Wakanda and placing her under
Black Panther’s protection does make sense, since it provides some
rationalization for why SHIELD, the X-Men, and the Consortium aren’t
actively pursuing her. I don’t think anyone at the time truly bought
into the idea that this was the “real” Storm, which didn’t stop
Claremont from keeping his poker face up and continuing the effort to
sell her as a villain. I actually admire that level of “What is
this?” storytelling, since I can’t deny that I loved those kinds of
stunts during the later years of Claremont’s original run. The novelty
of the Black Panther and Storm getting married has already been
exhausted by Marvel’s bizarre decision to do that story in the
mainstream titles, but Claremont does have two advantages. One, he
wrote the initial story that hinted at a romance between the pair, and
two, he’s set this plot over the course of several months. It still
comes across as rushed and somewhat arbitrary (it’s not as if that Marvel Team-Up back-up that’s
used as the basis of their relationship was ever referenced, or even
reprinted, for decades), but the marriage is more defensible within the
context of this story. The Black Panther doesn’t personally know the
X-Men, so he’s more inclined to believe Storm’s side of the story, and
this Storm was good enough to fool her friends for months, so it’s
not inconceivable that the Black Panther would also fall for her charms.
The decision to actually kill
the Black Panther, however, is another instance of the book doing
exactly what an alternate reality book shouldn’t do -- remind you that
it’s an alternate reality book. Again, the premise of this title is
“What if Chris Claremont never left X-Men?”
Not “What if Chris Claremont had free reign over the Marvel Universe?”
Black Panther wasn’t considered a real priority of Marvel’s in the
early ‘90s, but certainly he wouldn’t have been whacked in an issue of X-Men. (Well, maybe if Jim Lee really wanted
to do it, I could possibly see that happening, but only then.
Nevertheless, it’s the type of event that, under reasonable
circumstances, would not happen in X-Men.)
Killing off a major MU figure in this title just feels fundamentally
wrong, taking the reader out of the story as soon as it happens.
Judging the book on its own merits, giving Claremont the benefit of the
doubt and assuming that this is an event that’s necessary for the story
to evolve…maybe that’s what the readers should do, but it’s impossible
to rationalize stories like this with what the original marketing told
us the book would be.
3 comments:
I'm totally with you on the business of killing Black Panther. Claremont would never have been allowed by Marvel editorial to do it in the 90s, and doing it here is not playing fair with the series' supposed conceit. But compared with his upcoming handling of Iron Man, this is nothing!
I've always kind of liked the name Perfect Storm for evil Storm. It's a great pun-name.
This is why the series ended up annoying me so much. Since the premise was "What if Claremont hadn't left in the early-90s?", it seemed like Claremont was trying to convince fans that he'd have done all of Marvel's recent big events, first.
Storm marries Black Panther.
Iron Man becomes evil.
I wanted to see Claremont show where he would've taken X-Men had he never left, not him pretending that he would've originally come up with these ideas a decade before Marvel did those stories.
It never occurred to me while reading the series that Claremont was intentionally making a statement about modern Marvel, but now it's hard not to notice that he keeps touching on their ideas.
Post a Comment