Showing posts with label david williams. Show all posts
Showing posts with label david williams. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

EXCALIBUR #91 – November 1995

“Baby I Love You”
Credits:
Warren Ellis (writer), David Williams, Mike Wieringo, Jeff Moy, & Mike Miller (pencilers), Mike Miller, M. Christian, & Philip Moy (inkers), Ariane Lenshoek & Malibu Hues (colors), Richard Starkings & Comicraft (lettering)


Summary

Peter Wisdom and Kitty Pryde convince the other members of Excalibur to go out for a drink. Moira suggests they go to a bar her father used to own. Wolfsbane is reluctant to go, but is reassured by Moira and Nightcrawler. At the bar, Kitty offers her nectarine juice. Moira asks Kitty and Wisdom what’s going on between them, and they reply that they like each other and want Wisdom to join Excalibur. Later, in the men’s room, Britanic and Nightcrawler tell Wisdom that he can join the team, but they threaten to kill him if he hurts Kitty. Later, Douglock asks Britanic why he drinks, and he responds that he’s drinking non-alcoholic beer because of his past abuse. After Moira gets extremely drunk, the team returns home. As Kitty and Wisdom kiss outside, Colossus approaches.


Commercial Break

There’s an ad from American Entertainment for a limited edition All New Exiles vs. X-Men #0 comic book. The normal version costs $7.50 (plus $4.95 US shipping and $9.95 for international) if you meet the deadline, and $10.00 if you order later. The “limited super-premium edition” costs $29.95 before the order deadline and $39.95 after the deadline. I would love to meet the person who paid over forty dollars for this comic book. I was still enough of a completist to consider the “regular” edition (which would still add up to over twelve dollars), but wisely opted against it. It almost seems as if Marvel was actively encouraging kids to just run away from comics at this point. I imagine that naïve speculators and hardcore completists would be the only people interested in this, and judging by the fact that it features Rogue (who left the X-Men by the time Juggernaut joined the Exiles) it doesn’t seem like it even fits into the continuity that completists try so hard to maintain.


Review

It’s a “quiet” issue, so there’s not a lot to say about it. All of the character interactions are fine, but it really doesn’t feel as if there’s enough here to justify an entire issue (the first ten pages just consist of the team flying to the bar after Kitty and Wisdom individually ask the others if they want to go out). It has a few humorous moments, such as Moira getting wasted and Douglock scientifically listing all of the reasons not to drink, and it does do a decent job of making the title feel more like a team book after three issues of “The Pryde & Wisdom Show”. Ellis also gets points for remembering that Wolfsbane and Brian Braddock don’t drink and using that continuity as actual story points (what exactly Kitty is drinking isn’t made clear, maybe because Marvel wasn’t sure of how old she was supposed to be at this point). The art is covered by four different pencilers for some reason (this book really has a hard time getting consistent artists during this period), but it looks surprisingly consistent for most of the issue.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

EXCALIBUR #90 – October 1995

Dream Nails 3 – Blood Eagle

Credits: Warren Ellis (writer), Ken Lashley, David Williams, Carlos Pacheco, & Larry Stroman (pencilers), Tom Wegrzyn, Mike Miller, Cam Smith, & Larry Stroman (inkers), Joe Rosas & Ariane Lenshoek and Malibu (colors), Richard Starkings & Comicraft (lettering)


Summary

Peter Wisdom is locked in a room with Black Air agent Shrine. Shrine is a psychic who’s been assigned to test an alien-derived virus on Wisdom. The virus reacts to stress and destroys human flesh when it senses agitation. Shrine forces Wisdom to relive painful memories, including his previous missions and his mother’s murder by a spree killer. Wisdom pushes his memory of one mission to the front of his mind. Shrine observes Wisdom heartlessly killing every terrorist in an arctic base. Shrine can’t take the horror and collapses, as Wisdom breaks out of the room.

On Muir Island, Wolfsbane arrives to spend time with her adopted mother, Moira MacTaggert. Amanda Sefton checks on Rory Campbell, fearful that his treatment of Spoor might push him closer to becoming Ahab. Rory promises her that his knowledge of a possible future forces him to stay in control. During his session with Spoor, the mutant notices that Rory has run out of mood stabilizers. Spoor uses his mutant power to alter people’s moods to make Rory more angry and aggressive. After Spoor mocks his feelings for Amanda, Rory assaults him. The laser pen senses violence and attacks Rory, severing his leg.

Shadowcat searches the Black Air base for Wisdom. Hiding from the guards, she stumbles across a room filled with samples of aliens. The Uncreated, a group of captive aliens who have escaped during the confusion, target Shadowcat. They want to know if she has a God. When she says yes, they explain that they found their creator in space and proved their superiority by killing it. They want recognition for their accomplishment, and will kill anyone who still worships God. Shadowcat phases through the Uncreated and runs into Wisdom. Wisdom uses his hot knives to blow up the base’s generators, covering their escape. While on their way home, Shadowcat sets their aircraft on autopilot and kisses Wisdom for the first time.


Continuity Notes

Black Air has a sample of the Phalanx labeled “Phalanx using Skrull form as template. Recovered June 1982”. Kitty points out that Black Air has known about the Phalanx years before they did, but this doesn't work. The Phalanx were given an origin in X-Factor #106, which said that they were created by a group of scientists working with Warlock's remains. Black Air couldn't have known about the Phalanx for thirteen years at this point since they didn't exist until after a story published in 1990. Ellis probably meant the Technarcy, which is the alien race Warlock belonged to. Black Air also has a sample Brood drone donated by the Hellfire Club.


Review

This is the rare double-sized issue that’s not tied to an anniversary. They weren’t totally uncommon in the ‘80s, especially during Claremont’s UXM run, but I think they had mostly died out by the ‘90s. The extra pages do make this issue feel more important, which is fitting since the title’s continuity does advance with the story. Wisdom officially quits Black Air and joins the team, Wolfsbane arrives, and Rory Campbell takes a giant step towards becoming Ahab. Since this series can’t seem to have a regular-sized issue without multiple artists, it’s not surprising that this is also a jam issue. The shifts between artists are jarring, but thankfully the artists are given specific scenes to draw instead of just random pages. Carlos Pacheco does a great job with the Uncreated, but those are really the only pages that stand out visually.


The scenes between Rory Campbell and Spoor have their moments, but having Rory forgetfully run out of his mood stabilizers is too convenient for me, especially after he gives a speech to Amanda about how important it is for him to stay in control. If the idea is that he subconsciously forgot the pills on purpose because he wanted an excuse to attack Spoor, that’s not a bad twist but there’s nothing in the comic to support that theory. Lashley’s storytelling also disappoints on the most important page, since it’s not clear what exactly happens to him. It’s not hard to see that Rory’s leg has been severed, but there’s another panel where it looks like the lasers might’ve hit his eye. Since he’s given absolutely no facial expression and he’s drawn in profile, it’s also possible that the panel is supposed to show that he’s just spotted the lasers becoming active. The outline of his right eye doesn’t match his left eye in the final panel, so I guess that’s supposed to confirm that his eye was damaged also, but it’s hard to say. Since this is the culmination of a storyline that had been building for around two years, it deserves better than this. I do like the fact that something actually happens to Rory, since I wasn’t expecting any major events that would obviously push him closer to becoming Ahab to happen so soon. I remember being excited when I first read this scene, and really being surprised that Ellis was willing to take things that far. I think the Rory/Ahab story has become another dropped storyline over the years (I vaguely remember it briefly coming up during the 1999 Apocalypse crossover and not going anywhere), but at the time this did feel exciting.


The Uncreated get a considerable introduction, taking up most of Shadowcat’s scenes, leading me to believe that Ellis intended them to become more important villains than they turned out to be (I think they were only used again in his Starjammers miniseries). I do like their bizarre origin and motivation, but they don’t prove to be a real threat to Kitty since she’s able to just phase through them (off-panel, at that). Peter Wisdom receives most of the attention here, as a number of pages are dedicated to flashbacks from his past. Ellis does a capable job on these scenes, but after a while they start to feel like the conventional dark material that most British writers bring to mainstream comics. The idea that Shrine just can’t take all of the nasty stuff in Wisdom’s past is a little silly, especially when he’s responding to Wisdom killing terrorists and not babies or anything. Did Black Air pick the wimpiest guy they could find to interrogate him? Revealing that Black Air has been designing weapons and viruses from the aliens is a cool concept, though, and I think Ellis gets some more mileage out of it as his run progresses. I liked this issue when it was first released, and I enjoyed rereading it today, even if the conclusions don’t exactly work. All of the setups are promising, but in the end, Kitty just phases past the aliens, Wisdom’s interrogator wimps out, and Rory Campbell’s fate is poorly conveyed by the art. It’s not bad at all, but it doesn’t feel like it has much of a payoff.

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

EXCALIBUR #89 – September 1995

Dream Nails 2 – Easy Tiger

Credits: Warren Ellis (writer), David Williams (penciler), Mike Miller, Mike Christian & Phillip Moy (inkers), Joe Rosas & Digital Chameleon (colors), Richard Starkings & Comicraft (lettering)


Summary

Shadowcat and Peter Wisdom go back to the spy hangout and meet an associate of Wisdom’s named Jardine. He tells them that he’s heard things about Dream Nails, the air base where Culley worked. They meet Jardine at his office that night, where they discuss Dream Nail’s cover name, “Easy Tiger”. Wisdom claims it's a codename for “Extra-Terrestrial”. When Wisdom steps outside, Jardine explains to Shadowcat that he’s helping him because Wisdom took three bullets saving his daughter years ago, even though she was a total stranger. Jardine tells Shadowcat that he does care about people, even if he chooses not to show it. Later, Wisdom and Shadowcat break into the Dream Nails base. When Wisdom demands to go in alone, Shadowcat chastises him for always acting on his own and covering up his feelings. She begins to wonder if she’s falling for him. The duo sneak through the base until they reach a computer terminal . While searching through Black Air’s files, they learn that Culley was exposed to extraterrestrial bacteria after an alien bit through his containment suit. Afraid that Black Air would turn him into a lab rat, he turned to Wisdom for help. Shadowcat saves the info to a disc, as armed guards enter. Cornered by two guards, Wisdom demands that Shadowcat save herself and leave with the disc. Meanwhile, Rory Campbell has his first session with Spoor while Meggan and Douglock study the Legacy Virus. They tell Moira that their research shows that there is no pattern to the infections, and that the virus behaves unnaturally.


Continuity Notes

Wisdom’s friend “Cully” is now spelled “Culley”, which may or may not have been changed to make the X-Files connection less obvious (add an “S” to the front). Wisdom claims that he’s ten years older than Kitty. Kitty says that she’s been an X-Man since she was fourteen (although she was listed as thirteen in her first appearance).

Spoor’s real name is revealed as Andrew Hamish Graves. Rory Campbell claims that Spoor’s father killed his mother by forcing her to drink paint thinner, and then told Spoor she ran away.


Review

Ellis makes a big step in the Pryde/Wisdom romance by revealing for the first time that the characters have feelings for one another that they’re trying to hide. It does seem a little forced, and the idea that Wisdom secretly has a heart of gold under his cynical demeanor is certainly a cliché at this point. Their romance never really bothered me, though, mainly because I’ve seen more random real-life couples, and it doesn’t exactly floor me that a teenager (even the precious Kitty Pryde) would be drawn towards a gruff, older man. The action in this issue is essentially the same as the previous one, only now the Black Air agents are wearing body armor and carrying giant ‘90s-style guns instead of wearing suits and packing handguns. I guess that’s excusable, since this isn’t an action-oriented issue and most of the story is spent on building up the Dream Nails mystery and developing Shadowcat and Wisdom’s relationship. Those aspects work, even if the plot doesn’t advance very far. The story continues to reference the Legacy Virus plotline, even though this is the second issue in a row that someone makes a revelation about the virus that goes nowhere. I’m not sure if the Legacy Virus hints or the Onslaught hints are more annoying. David Williams does a nice fill-in job, drawing in a sparse, cartoony style that looks pretty contemporary with something published today.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...