Wednesday, September 19, 2007

UNCANNY X-MEN #283 – December 1991


Bishop’s Crossing


Credits: Whilce Portacio (plot, pencils), Art Thibert (inks), John Byrne (script), Tom Orzechowski and Lois Buhalis (letters), Joe Rosas (colors)


Summary
Bishop, Malcolm, and Randall emerge from a time portal and attempt to capture Fitzroy. The X-Men are shocked to see Bishop ruthlessly kill Fitzroy’s henchmen. Bishop is convinced that the X-Men are impostors and they begin to fight. Fitzroy is taken away by the Upstarts while Bishop fights the X-Men. The Upstarts detonate explosives in Fitzroy’s base, forcing the X-Men to leave without Bishop. Meanwhile, Xavier returns Jean’s mind to her own body. Finally, the individuals behind the Upstart competition are revealed to be Selene and the Gamesmaster.


Continuity Notes
Xavier senses another mind when returning Jean to her own body. I’m assuming this is Emma Frost.


Shaw’s upset with Fitzroy for stealing his ring of leadership and has him placed in manacles. I don’t think the idea of a leadership ring for the Upstarts is brought up again. Shaw toasts the other Upstarts in victory; none of these characters are identified or seen again, but they all have stylish outfits.


Selene threatens that the Upstarts won’t like the true nature of their prize.


Review
It’s the conclusion to the first story arc in the new direction of Uncanny X-Men, and it’s more of the same. This issue marks the first full appearance of Bishop (even though he was on the cover of the previous issue, he barely appeared there). According to legend, Bishop was the first X-Man created solely for marketing reasons. Marvel’s marketing department wanted a new X-Man, and they wanted him to be black. Gun toting tough guys were also really popular back then, so there you go.

Portacio’s plot remains questionable, leaving the scripting to cover up some of the shortcomings. Byrne tries to explain why Bishop is suddenly more interested in fighting the X-Men than capturing Fitzroy by saying that time travel is “disorienting”. He also tries to cover how exactly Jean developed the new power to transfer her mind into someone else’s body by having Forge say “necessity is the mother of invention”. Okay then. In another goofy scene, Shinobi Shaw tells Fitzroy that his Sentinels re-attached his severed fingers. Those giant robots must be very skilled surgeons. I’d love to see them perform such delicate surgery with their enormous robotic fingers. It would actually be more interesting than anything in this issue.


The introduction of the Upstarts themselves is handled just as sloppily as anything else in this arc. Considering the fact that the Upstart competition is driving the plot in this series and its spinoff, it should have received a much clearer introduction. Unless I missed something in one of Portacio’s X-Factor issues, I don’t think one single issue so far has given readers the basics of the competition. Apparently, they kill super-powered beings for points, and this issue introduces the Gamemaster as the arbitrator of the competition. What’s the prize of the competition? It’s a mystery. What does Gamemaster get out of this? It’s a mystery. Why is Selene in league with the Gamemaster? It’s a mystery.


Theoretically, this should be a very important storyline. It’s the first story since the original X-Men rejoined the team, something fans had been demanding for years. It’s the death of several established characters. It’s the introduction of several new villains. It’s the introduction of a brand new X-Man! Yet, due to the frantic pacing of each issue, it’s impossible to care about any of this.

2 comments:

Cove West said...

Y'know, I don't think I've ever read UXM #283. I know I have the issue somewhere, I just could never stomach enough energy to read a conclusion to #282. I can stand #281 because it's a landmark issue and it has an interesting set up (along with some wild, non-sensical energy), but anything after than until the 300's gets progressively more confused.

In fact, both UNCANNY and X-MEN somehow managed to hit their all-time sensical lows at exactly the same time. Does ANYTHING in the Spring of 1992 in the core titles of Marvel's cash cow make even the slightest bit of sense? Yeah, Liefeld's X-FORCE was terrible and some of the post-Onslaught stuff was hardly worth printing, but nothing the X-books have ever done is as shoddily written as these issues of UNCANNY and X-MEN.

And boy, does all that "Bishop's alternate future" hysteria look embarassing these days? Remember when fans clamored for the return of Malcolm and/or Randall? When the Gambit/Witness/Bishop thing was basically the only story X-MEN was telling for a year or two? When the X-Traitor mystery drove us nuts? When Bishop's sister's holgraphic-image-from-the-future became a member of X-Factor? When UXM #282-283 were 100 bucks if you could find them? I can't even remember what we were all so excited about anymore...

PeterCSM said...

Nobody respects leadership rings these days! I never understood the Upstarts either as a kid or adult. Nor did I understand Gamemaster. Did any of this become of anything? I know Fabian Cortez tries to kill Magneto for the Upstarts and I think Siena Blaze was one, but what was the point? You win and become leader of the Upstarts and then what? You get to eat a very nice array of cheeses while wearing a vibranium crown?

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...